Andy Burnham's proposed devolution plans for England, which aim to transfer significant power and money to local mayors and councils, have been largely welcomed. However, publishers and experts emphasize the critical need for stronger local media to ensure accountability and scrutiny of these newly empowered local governments. The shift from Westminster risks weakening oversight as regional titles contend with hostility, the influence of big tech, and the proliferation of "news deserts."
The central idea of Burnham's premiership is English devolution, designed to address an "unaccountable state" that is both too powerful and too distant. While the intention to empower communities is seen as positive, the vastly diminished state of local government scrutiny poses a significant challenge. The plan to grant mayors a share of income tax generated in their areas, a concept supported by economists to address regional inequalities, will necessitate deeper forms of accountability.
Under Burnham's proposals, mayors will gain the ability to borrow for large projects and retain a share of income tax revenues starting in 2028, alongside business rates by April 2027. These funds are intended to replace existing central government grants, offering local leaders more autonomy. However, the success of this "biggest transfer of power from Westminster in a generation" hinges on the ability of local media to effectively scrutinize decisions and expenditures, preventing a mere illusion of control without robust oversight. Organizations like the News Media Association stress that genuine local control requires trusted and professional local scrutiny.
