Nike's stock is on track for its steepest annual decline since Michael Jordan's 1993 retirement, with shares plummeting 38.6% year-to-date in 2026 and over 48% in the past 12 months. The company's stock recently hit a 12-year low of $39.09 on August 17, marking a 78% drop from its November 2021 peak. This downturn has wiped out approximately $196 billion in shareholder wealth, reflecting deep investor concerns about the pace and effectiveness of CEO Elliott Hill's turnaround strategy.

Analysts are increasingly cautious, with JPMorgan downgrading Nike to Underweight and slashing its price target to $40, citing that the financial impact of Hill's "Win Now" strategy will pressure earnings through at least fiscal year 2028. This suggests that 2028 will be a year of "stabilization" rather than significant growth. Other firms like RBC Capital and Stifel have reiterated neutral "Hold" ratings and $45 price targets, pointing to limited near-term catalysts and a slower-than-projected execution of the recovery plan, exacerbated by industry lead times and geopolitical conflicts.

Adding to the concerns, a 2026 back-to-school survey revealed Nike's brand popularity at 45.8% of retail checks, a recovery from 2025's all-time low of 38.2%, but still significantly below its 2021 peak of 92.5%. The company faces structural headwinds including weak digital demand, softening sales in Greater China, and rising competition. Nike's Greater China revenue, once a growth engine, declined 11% to $5.85 billion in FY2026, marking eight consecutive quarters of decline and a 30% drop from its 2021 peak, partly due to a planned digital reset that will introduce a $1 billion annual headwind from January 2027.