In a special Father's Day episode of "The Deal with Alex Rodriguez and Jason Kelly," the usual roles were reversed as the hosts welcomed their own children as guests. Alex Rodriguez's daughters, Natasha and Ella Rodriguez, offered a humorous look into their father's past as a musical theater performer and his struggles with TikTok trends. They also provided style advice, highlighting endearing family memories and giving listeners a unique glimpse into the retired baseball star's personal life.

Jason Kelly's sons, Henry and Will, also joined the conversation, revealing insights into their father's passionate fandom for the Knicks and discussing his role in teaching them to appreciate sports. They playfully compared a family member to Josh Hart, providing a lighthearted moment during the episode. The appearance of their children offered a fresh and candid perspective on the two usually analytical hosts, showcasing their personalities outside of their business and sports-focused discussions.

The episode concluded with Jason Kelly's daughter, Alice Kelly, posing a particularly pressing question to Alex Rodriguez: whether he likes Pokémon. This unexpected query added a touch of humor and innocence to the segment, underscoring the informal and personal nature of the Father's Day special. The episode aimed to offer listeners a more intimate understanding of Alex Rodriguez and Jason Kelly, featuring the perspectives of their "biggest critics" – their own children.